Marriage isn't meant to make you happy: unrealistic expectations and covenant
Ricardo Martins on why expecting your spouse to be the source of your happiness crushes any marriage — what Jeremiah 2, Malachi 2, Ephesians 5 and Philippians 2 teach about covenant, unrealistic expectations and the joy only God can give.

Few people say it out loud, but a lot of people think it: “I got married to be happy. If I’m not happy, something went wrong — and it’s probably his fault. Or hers.”
It sounds reasonable. The love songs say it. The rom-coms say it. Every perfectly filtered couple on your feed says it. Find “the one,” and life will click into place. And when life doesn’t click — when the credit card bill is late, the baby won’t sleep, the routine gets heavy and the car ride home is dead silent — the conclusion shows up fast: “I married the wrong person.”
I want to offer you a different way to see it. Not so you’ll settle for a miserable marriage, but so you can lift a weight off your spouse that they were never built to carry.
The expectation that crushes anyone
When I expect my spouse to be the source of my happiness, I’m handing them a job that belongs to God. And no human being can do that job.
The prophet Jeremiah paints this mistake with a vivid picture:
“My people have committed two sins: They have forsaken me, the spring of living water, and have dug their own cisterns, broken cisterns that cannot hold water.” (Jeremiah 2:13)
A broken cistern is a cracked well. You fill it, fill it, fill it — and tomorrow it’s empty again. That’s exactly what happens when I demand from my husband or my wife what only God can give me: identity, security, meaning, peace. He will fall short. She will fall short. Not because they’re bad people, but because they’re people.
And it snowballs. The more I demand, the more disappointed I get. The more disappointed I get, the more I criticize. The more I criticize, the further away my spouse drifts. Marriages rarely die from a lack of love. They drown in expectations that were never theirs to meet.
Contract vs. covenant
Our culture treats marriage like a contract: I deliver, you deliver; if you stop delivering, I’m off the hook. Contracts are great for leasing a car. They’re terrible for marriage.
Scripture uses a different word: covenant. When God confronts the men of Israel who were walking out on their wives, He says:
“It is because the LORD is the witness between you and the wife of your youth. You have been unfaithful to her, though she is your partner, the wife of your marriage covenant.” (Malachi 2:14)
Notice that God is the witness. Marriage isn’t a private deal between two people who like each other as long as it works out. It’s a vow made before the Lord, and it doesn’t depend on how this week is going.
A contract asks, “What am I getting out of this?” A covenant asks, “Who did I promise to be?” Changing that one question can change the whole atmosphere of a home.
The model is the cross, not a fairy tale
If marriage isn’t mainly about making me happy, what is it for? Paul answers by pointing to Jesus:
“Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her.” (Ephesians 5:25)
Christ didn’t love the church because she was charming or because she paid Him back well. He gave Himself up. Marriage is a living picture of that love — a man and a woman learning, day after day, to give themselves the way Christ gave Himself.
Here’s the part most of us miss: God uses marriage to change us. Romans says He works in all things for the good of those who love Him, and that the goal is for us to be “conformed to the image of his Son” (Romans 8:28-29). Author Gary Thomas put it memorably in the subtitle of his book Sacred Marriage: what if God designed marriage to make us holy more than to make us happy?
That means the habit of hers that drives you up the wall, or that stubborn streak of his, might be the very sandpaper God is using to smooth out your selfishness. Marriage is a school where Christ is the teacher.
This is not a call to suffer in silence
Let me be crystal clear. Saying marriage isn’t meant to make you happy does not mean you should put up with violence, abuse, humiliation or betrayal and do nothing. Covenant is not captivity. If you’re in danger, get help now — from your church, from qualified professionals, and from the authorities when needed. God hates violence as much as He loves marriage.
What I’m talking about is something else: the ordinary disappointments of two imperfect people sharing one life. The “I thought it would be more than this” feeling. The boredom. The letdown. That’s where resetting your expectations can save a marriage.
How to reset your expectations
1. Bring your emptiness to God first. Before you put it on your spouse, ask: “What am I looking for in them that I should be looking for in the Lord?” David knew where full joy lives: “you will fill me with joy in your presence” (Psalm 16:11). When you drink from the spring, you stop demanding water from the cistern.
2. Turn expectations into agreements. An expectation is something I pictured in my head and never said. An agreement is something we decided together. A lot of fights start with an unspoken expectation: “He should have known I wanted that.” Say it. Talk it through. Turn the expectation into a conversation.
3. Change your morning question. Instead of waking up wondering, “Will she make me happy today?”, try: “How can I serve my wife today?” Paul wrote: “not looking to your own interests but each of you to the interests of the others” (Philippians 2:4). It sounds small. It changes everything.
4. Stop comparing with the couple on your screen. You’re comparing the behind-the-scenes of your marriage with everyone else’s highlight reel. Nobody posts Tuesday night’s argument.
5. Celebrate what’s real. Your spouse isn’t perfect, but they probably do a lot you’ve stopped noticing. Gratitude is the antidote to frustrated expectations.
The paradox: stop demanding happiness and you’ll often find it
Here’s God’s irony. When you stop demanding that marriage make you happy and start living the covenant — serving, forgiving, choosing to stay — joy tends to show up along the way. Not as a paycheck, but as fruit.
I know this firsthand. I was once the problem in my own marriage. Vanessa gave God a chance. And trust was rebuilt brick by brick. It wasn’t some magical feeling that carried us; it was a covenant before God, renewed every single day.
If your marriage feels like a cracked cistern right now, don’t start by looking for a new well. Go back to the spring. God still knows how to restore what looks bone-dry — and He usually starts with whoever is willing to take the first step.
Want to talk with Ricardo & Vanessa?
Follow the daily videos on YouTube and Instagram — real testimony, practical steps, and hope for marriages that look finished.
Watch on YouTubeThis content is educational and pastoral. It does not replace therapy, medical, legal or emergency help. If you are in danger, seek help now.


